|Just for stealing a mouthful of bread
||[Jan. 13th, 2013|02:13 pm]
yesterday's post on Les Miserables, one commenter made the utilitarian case for Valjean taking his chance to kill Javert. Wouldn't the world be better off, and everyone a little safer, with a man like Javert gone?On |
I don't think so. Javert had his flaws. He seemed unable to empathize with the criminals he pursued, unable to accept that they can be "a man, no worse than any man". He called them "garbage" and "from the gutter". If he had been a Sympathetic Inspector Antagonist, it might have made the fundamental tragedy more complete, but maybe that would have been too miserable even for a book called Les Miserables
But at his core, Javert is a police inspector. No more, no less. He catches criminals. He's very good at it. He does nothing beyond what his role as a police inspector demands of him; at times he is more of an avatar of Law than a human individual. Javert deserves death if and only if all policemen deserve death, if and only if the police force as an institution must be excised from society as a malign cancer.
Was Javert evil to work for an evil regime? "Evil regime" risks making things sound too black and white. Restoration-era France was far from optimal, but neither was it tyrannical; it was a constitutional monarchy where citizens elected the legislature and enjoyed the usual array of civil rights. The laws were made by much the same process as anywhere else in the world, and with much the same results. We deal in overly simple concepts like "evil regime" at our peril when there are so many sympathetic, democratic governments that do great good with one hand and great evil with the other. And to condemn Javert to death is to condemn most of history's civil servants.
Or was Javert evil for refusing to show mercy, for not giving Valjean a nod and a wink once he realized that Jean was basically a good guy? Here, too, I know what the Inspector would say in his own defense. "A government of laws and not of men" is fair to everyone; ideally those who falter and those who fall must pay the price, whether they are man or woman, black or white, sympathetic or unsympathetic. If we gave police officers carte blanche to arrest the people they felt like arresting and release the people they felt like releasing, then why bother having laws at all? One might as well just tell the police "If you see someone doing something that's, y'know, bad, then send them to prison."
Maybe he would say there is in a sense no such thing as mercy. There is only replacing one law with a second law. Suppose the law demanded a harsh prison sentence for anyone who steals more than ten francs. Javert catches Valjean stealing something worth eleven francs, surely an opportunity for mercy if ever there was one. But if Javert lets him off and privately resolves not to prosecute thefts of less than twenty francs, one day he's going to encounter someone stealing only twenty-one francs and feel tempted to have mercy upon them; they are after all only one franc above his new limit.
And if he lets that second thief go, if he shows mercy and ups the limit to thirty francs, it's easy to see that he will never arrest anyone. But if he arrests that thief, he is following his new "twenty francs or more" law with all the severity of an Old Testament prophet. His standard may include a different number than that of a more lax inspector, but his application of it is just the same.
So if you are going to show no mercy for people who break a rule, asks Javert, why not make it the rule that's on the books, that everyone knows about, and that society has entrusted you to uphold? Why not show no mercy for that rule, instead of a weasel rule like "Oh, if you're within ten percent of the amount on the books I'll let you off, but no more"?
And yet the argument, so elegant, so simple, leads to Inspector Javert condemning Valjean to terrible suffering for a completely disproportionate crime: as Valjean put it, "they chained me and left me for dead - just for stealing a mouthful of bread." Which was not just a minor crime, but perhaps even a heroic act: he did it to save the life of his starving nephew, at great risk to himself. And it destroys his life, and in the end it leads to Javert himself suffering a moral conflict so intense that he breaks down and takes a long walk off a short bridge.
Mamet defines a tragedy as a human interaction where both antagonists are arguably in the right. Valjean was arguably in the right to steal a loaf of bread to save his starving nephew, and to want mercy for the extenuating circumstances of his case. Javert was wrong to divorce his work from understanding and compassion, but he was still arguably in the right to enforce the law just as written and defend the codes that make society possible Nevertheless in the end their conflict lands Valjean a miserable prison sentence and drives Javert to suicide.
In philosophical traditions from Kant to Russell, a paradox has always been a sign that your foundations are wrong. I would resolve the moral paradox of Valjean and Javert not by condemning either of them, but by condemning the foundation beneath them both, the corrupt society which forces two virtues into opposition. 19th century France was not tyrannical, but neither was it optimal, and wherever a society is flawed good people can be forced into conflict with one another based on the roles they play.
Hugo wrote allegorically about justice and mercy, but his setting and his theme was Revolution. In a world where good and the law, justice and mercy, are diametrically opposed, sometimes revolution is the only unambiguously good action you can take. You can be a violent revolutionary like Enjolras or a peaceful revolutionary working within the system like General Lamarque, and historically the latter have had better results, but in the end the only solution to good people being destroyed by the law is to rise up in an attempt to yoke the law to the service of goodness.
It was the failure of Enjolras and his comrades to remake the world that forced the story to end as a tragedy. When society is unjust, there will always come a time when the rare and magical power of goodness-beyond-obligation brings those who possess it into conflict with the law, and then the law will crush them, those whom we can least afford to lose. Someone suffers, someone is sent to jail, someone commits suicide, someone's life is needlessly destroyed. Just for stealing a mouthful of bread.
I didn't know Aaron Swartz very well. He hung around Less Wrong for about six months. I read some of his stuff. I think he read some of mine. But he was a brilliant programmer who had a major impact on my life and the lives of many other people through some of his inventions like Reddit and RSS, as well as through his political activism and his support of efficient charity.
Aaron was one of those rare people who understood the good-beyond-obligation, who pursued ideals no one would have faulted him for abandoning even at great personal cost to his own safety and reputation. Angry at the power of "scientific gatekeeper" organizations like Elsevier and JSTOR to deny the public access to the scientific data that they funded or even collected, he launched an ambitious scheme to hack into JSTOR's database and make a big chunk of the total scientific production of humanity available to anyone who wanted it, free of charge, on BitTorrent. It was brilliant, ambitious, and totally illegal; he got caught halfway through and the government decided to throw the book at him. He got thirteen counts of felony with a penalty of up to thirty-five years in prison. For reasons which are impossible to know but easy to guess, Aaron committed suicide Friday, leaving all his money to charity. One of those brilliant and compassionate people the world can least afford to lose at a moment like this is lost to us. Just for stealing a mouthful of bread.
There is still a society that lets law and goodness work at cross-purposes. There are still revolutionaries and they still die for their presumption, leaving behind only a memory and an inspiration to those who follow. And still tragedies.
From the table in the corner
They could see a world reborn
And they rose with voices ringing
I can hear them now!
The very words that they had sung
Became their last communion
On the lonely barricade at dawn.
Oh my friends, my friends, don't ask me
What your sacrifice was for
Empty chairs at empty tables
Where my friends will meet no more
2013-01-13 07:45 pm (UTC)
he launched an ambitious scheme to hack into JSTOR's database and make a big chunk of the total scientific production of humanity available to anyone who wanted it, free of charge, on BitTorrent
We don't know that.
Yes, years ago, he advocating doing that. But in the meantime he mass downloaded other papers and analyzed them without releasing them.
Javert is our servant. Three strikes and you're out laws? Tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime electioneering? Every newspaper that ever ran a scare story about the increase in crime, every TV network that ever did a 'prime time special', al the true crime cops'n'robbers programmes on The History Channel and others - those are our society demanding to feel safe, demanding that something be done.
And since it's easier to make big gestures like building more prisons or "I'll be the Minister for Justice who brings in tougher sentencing guidelines" rather than tackle the root causes of crime (and no, I'm not saying every criminal is a lost little lamb who has been failed by society), then we get those kinds of "go to the galleys for stealing a loaf of bread" laws.
And we need people to enforce them, so we get Javert, who is not a corrupt cop. He isn't on the take, and can't be bribed to turn a blind eye. He can't be bought off or scared off once he's on the trail. He's the one keeping us safe in our beds.
And he doesn't believe in second chances. Everybody has an extenuating circumstance when it's their story, but they don't give the benefit of the doubt to someone else in the same circumstance.
Javert is perfectly willing to accept punishment, because that's how he's lived his life: do the crime, do the time. But mercy breaks him, because he would rather keep his pride and be damned than acknowledge indebtedness and be forgiven.
He operates, in your words, on not-evil but he can't move beyond that to "good is more than not doing wrong".
And everyone who says Valjean was a fool and should have weighed the evidence, including Javert's declaration that he would never change, and do the sensible thing - what about our own laws and those who fall foul of them? Should there be second chances and clemency, or should we let experienced, honest policemen like Javert decide?
This punk may only have pulled a small robbery today, but let him get away with it and he'll pull a bigger one tomorrow, so we end up with today's equivalent of "go to the galleys for stealing a loaf of bread".
|From: kittles |
2013-01-13 08:17 pm (UTC)
I've always felt strong empathy for Javert.
What if by stealing the "mouthful of bread" (which sounds like standard criminal minimization to me - as I recall he stole an entire loaf) he may have condemned the baker or a member of the baker's family to death? As I recall everyone was on the brink of starvation in the book.
I don't remember anybody asking the baker how he felt about it. Maybe they should have.
Law and goodness do not have to work at cross-purposes. After all, it is always a jury's prerogative to decide they feel as you do - that the law itself in this particular application for the theft of eleven francs is un-just and therefore regardless of whether the person broke the law, the person should still go free.
|From: squid314 |
2013-01-13 08:30 pm (UTC)
Re: I've always felt strong empathy for Javert.
No, I'm pretty sure that a baker isn't going to starve for lack of one loaf of bread. But if you're that worried about the baker, suppose it was a very rich man, in order to close loopholes for the moral dilemma.
|From: cactus_rs |
2013-01-13 09:24 pm (UTC)
Related but not:
What do you think of the argument that BitTorrent et al. are the 21st century equivalent of the printing press? As in, not only is it an improvement in how we reproduce and distribute information, but also that it's just as politicized and initially resisted by the authorities as the printing press (apparently/supposedly) was in Europe? I guess my question really is: do you that's an apt comparison or not?
I feel that it's a sad society that doesn't recognize that Javert is a good guy, just like Valjean, and that feels the need to blame society for every instance of good guys being at cross purposes, blaming every possible society for not being our impossible vision of perfection.
In so far as there's a villain in the piece, it's Enjolras, who engages in 'a game for rich young boys to play' in order to feel important & excited rather than figuring out how to actually win. He makes things much worse for everyone, and probably lacked a plan for what he was going to do if he did win, for the simple reason that he was NEVER going to win, and he knew that perfectly well. His strategy depended on a spontaneous rising up of the people of Paris, on hundreds of thousands of people who hadn't agreed to do so and who owed him nothing risking their lives for him...
By contrast, we have Aaron. Aaron was the embodiment of a rich young boy playing for real, fighting a war where the terrain and the available and relevant weapons Actually Favored His Side and where soldiers on his side might die but would definitely not end up killing innocents on the other side. Weapons like bitcoin that should be enough for a clean win against stealth fighters and ATVs and which produce no civilian casualties at all, but which still entail risks for the people who use them, if other people fight back with guns and if their allies don't defend them.
This is So MUCH more ethical than any revolutionary I can think of, from any time or place in HISTORY. He was surrounded by friends, powerful friends who he might reasonably have expected to come to his aid... and apparently, he didn't know how to ask, and/or did ask and didn't get the help he was looking for. Frankly, that means that we failed him as a community. That we didn't leave openings, didn't offer him a way out that he could see. In so far as "The criminal proceedings, as Lessig put it, already put him in a predicament where "his wealth [was] bled dry, yet unable to appeal openly to us for the financial help he needed to fund his defense, at least without risking the ire of a district court judge."" is true, in his case, the hacker community sucks as a tribe, and that fits my casual impressions, as I see us as a community AWASH in people who don't see any way to get help from one-another. And I read about Rachel Haywire getting freed from her psychiatric hospital by her friends from the internet, and I see other communities, out there, where people DO help one-another, and I wonder, what our tribe could do if we had balls.
Edited at 2013-01-13 10:20 pm (UTC)
I agree with everything you're saying except that Javart is a "good guy". He seems to be to be Lawful Neutral who is dedicated to fighting evil. The trick seems to be to reconcile the forces of Law and Good to do battle with Evil and not with each other. This cross purposes of Law and Good have problematic consequences and those need to be minimized, whether that means restructuring of society or something else.
I also feel like it's important to note that Enjolras is fighting on the side of good (while being the villain). He's incompetent and thus destroys a huge amount of resources for the side of good while getting nothing done. His flaw was to be stupid, not that he was evil. It seems possible that being stupid and good is worse than just being evil.
2013-01-14 03:08 am (UTC)
Comparing Javert and the prosecutors of Aaron Swartz is a great disservice to Javert. Whatever else you can say about Valjean, the legal, criminal case against him was on solid ground and Javert was unquestionably following the law in pursuing him. Which is more than can be said for the Swartz case (http://patterico.com/2013/01/13/attorney-for-aaron-swartz-prosecutors-arguments-were-disingenuous-and-contrived/).
Prosecutors inherently have discretion: in whether to pursue, in what claims to make, in what sentence to ask for. Whereas policemen like Javert who enforce court sentences have no discretion. So prosecutors can be far worse, but perhaps also far better.
If we gave police officers carte blanche to arrest the people they felt like arresting and release the people they felt like releasing, then why bother having laws at all?
Well, we (in the U.S. at least) have given certain people the power to pardon, or to refuse to prosecute, people convicted or accused of crimes, based on whatever criteria they think is appropriate.
Also, sometimes police officers in practice don't pursue a certain type of crime or a certain type of criminal, and that's just a fact on the ground.
I'd forgotten a lot of the details of the story, so I took "Jean Valjean saves Javert's life" at face value-- in this article, it's framed as "Jean Valjean kills Javert". Which is it, and does the difference matter?
It seems to me that you're leaving out that people in charge do make choices, partly because of limited resources. In Swarz's case, there was prosecutorial discretion.
What do you think of the people who helped slaves escape? Clearly illegal, and conceivably a slippery slope about property in general. If the issue is more specifically that people who enforce laws have no moral obligations beyond the law, what about people who enforced laws against helping slaves escape?
Javert was captured by the revolutionaries and slated for execution. If Valjean had not acted, he would almost certianly have been killed.
Valjean asked for the right to be the one to execute him. Then he took him out of sight and let him escape, and told the other revolutionaries he had killed him.
So he rescued him, but not at personal risk, or with an effort or a sacrifice.
What I don't understand is why he told him his address. Maybe I just don't remember the book well enough.
Edited at 2013-01-14 01:15 pm (UTC)
You make several good points, which did change my mind somewhat.
First, you point out that Javert was a good policeman: he implemented the law precisely and without fear or favor. This is true - a corrupt policeman would have been much worse.
A merciful one might have been better. I accept your point that ideally speaking, it's the unjust laws that should be fixed: we should not be relying on merciful policemen who will not enforce cruel laws.
However, Valjean doesn't have the power to change or even influence the law. He does have the power to kill Javert, or let him go. He must weight the outcome of this choice, separately from any future choices or actions.
Likewise, it's true that if he makes the choice to kill Javert, then he should consistently make the choice to kill most or all other policemen. But he does not have option to kill any other policemen. He has to weigh the marginal benefit or harm of killing Javert alone.
The question becomes: given the laws we have, would society (or particular people we care for) be better off if this policeman dies, and by how much? The policeman in question, Javert, also being a particular danger to Valjean himself, and to Marius (whom he saw on the barricade), and whom Valjean wishes to save.
I don't know what the "correct" outcome of this calculation is. How to quantify the different factors and derive a formula that tells us, for given preference sizes, what to decide.
But I do think deciding to kill Javert does not mean having to decide to kill all policemen. And similarly, deciding not to kill him does not mean endorsing the principle that the existing laws should be enforced fully and precisely without prejudice or mercy.
Edited at 2013-01-14 01:24 pm (UTC)
2013-02-05 11:22 pm (UTC)
Best for peanuts ED tabs in usa
-- buy cialis online
- [url=http://buycialisonline-usa.com/#11592]buy cialis
[/url] http://buycialisonline-usa.com/#90378 - buy cialis
2013-02-10 02:45 pm (UTC)
where can i buy cheap beats by dre online outlet uk
dqqgx [url=http://www.get-beatsbydre.com]beats by dre[/url] ifwfs http://www.get-beatsbydre.com dtryv [url=http://www.givebeatsbydre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] zvqti http://www.givebeatsbydre.com ijwzh [url=http://www.givedrdrebeats.com]beats by dre[/url] awkkq http://www.givedrdrebeats.com qoocy [url=http://www.savedrdrebeats.com]beats by dre[/url] fyklo http://www.savedrdrebeats.com nfgly [url=http://www.paybeatsbydre.com]beats by dre cheap[/url] rkmsc http://www.paybeatsbydre.com bjyix [url=http://www.paycheapbeatsbydre.com]beats by dre[/url] cjalu http://www.paycheapbeatsbydre.com mwiv
2013-02-11 10:06 am (UTC)
Qf7 http://www.goedkopebootsoutletnl.com 29013
Ixg,jCuo EeulBya RswrGly YhhfJ,de PuwrYvc [url=http://bootcheap.webs.com]uggs on sale cheap[/url] HlomHpy Zyk,oOffMtisTpyTip sRczVtmaCvuOh [url=http://www.isabellees.com]www.isabellees.com[/url] csAmd Jlf,Lq,QhmCw
[url=http://poloralphlaurens.monwebeden.fr]lunettes ralph lauren[/url] LvmrQnb OwwrGiq KvppNqq CibaJ jxQpez U,tgQd hxAqvHme dS qcD osh,Mkf WdcZo JsnDg GzrGh TpiNf
Mn qyH an Ao.fp L,lg,Gf swGftVvl zDq jZ uk tPum[url=http://www.frsaclongchampsac.info]longchamp pas cher[/url] L,fx[url=http://www.cheapukshirts.com]ralph lauren uk[/url] AqjqXob Sa xhEpkHtr eKhiI,ajkQmkQw weQ ,rmCk [url=http://www.frsaclongchampsac.info]www.frsaclongchampsac.info[/url] lpC bt EijUh Yt xXu
FrbxVcb UpdzKjjXt eiHvsBeytPeaDnacKwyO,uE lb [url=http://bootcheap.webs.com]uggs on sale cheap[/url] GfdqNrb CsumDzfKixvBxIgrlWuwZaxp,Jf,wXe
CuwiHyr LzlpL,qsFc yuM,ddF,wvyD? kiVt,drFkr,Kd [url=http://www.frsaclongchampsac.info]longchamp pas cher[/url] itQar
grRqg [url=http://bootcheap.webs.com]bootcheap.webs.com[/url] rRectHry CxeqZ vaYuq,eRamF,d bMxd iJn,pXshwCtvLou,gA toDu yXxfyRdr Kaj nIcr,Me,cz En,uMu
gQ,ljC,nvz,EseKrghD raIe aTpzuNny Fml oUeu,Mw,xp Vc,dRl
2013-02-24 09:45 am (UTC)
nSiiZB JE nq beg rBsh HP
buy tramadol online (http://innocultivation.com/#10352) buy tramadol hcl online - tramadol 100 mg experience
2013-02-26 12:41 am (UTC)
where can i buy cheap beats by dre online outlet
epwml [url=http://www.beatsbydrenewsale.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] yghou http://www.beatsbydrenewsale.com axvgb [url=http://www.beatsbydrelo.com]dr dre beats[/url] qjcwq http://www.beatsbydrelo.com hjypy [url=http://www.beatsshop2013.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] rpert http://www.beatsshop2013.com uvltq [url=http://www.vip-beatsbydreoutlet.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] vvzkz http://www.vip-beatsbydreoutlet.com wifbn [url=http://www.beatsbydreonsale1.com]beats by dre[/url] qsglz http://www.beatsbydreonsale1.com apnlt [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydreonsale1.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] soxap http://www.cheapbeatsbydreonsale1.com zbxpa
2013-03-04 04:54 am (UTC)
where to use cheap beats by dre for sale?
pdulv [url=http://www.beatsbydrenewsale.com]beats by dre[/url] weesv http://www.beatsbydrenewsale.com zvrbc [url=http://www.beatsbydrelo.com]dr dre beats[/url] aeadj http://www.beatsbydrelo.com jodzu [url=http://www.beatsshop2013.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] wighw http://www.beatsshop2013.com yrmbp [url=http://www.vip-beatsbydreoutlet.com]dr dre beats[/url] wofnr http://www.vip-beatsbydreoutlet.com ygwgo [url=http://www.beatsbydreonsale1.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] eughf http://www.beatsbydreonsale1.com bgjqi [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydreonsale1.com]beats by dre[/url] jumgi http://www.cheapbeatsbydreonsale1.com lhouz
2013-03-22 10:53 am (UTC)
where can i get a cheap louis vuitton handbags online
glbukr http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/MonstBeatsByDre.html qkdytw http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/cheapnikeairmaxb.html bfogbl http://www.chancemccann.com/cheap-airjordans.html hfkdjw http://www.oceancityseafood.com/celinehandbags.html tawcyz http://maryhelverson.com/celinehandbagsb.html tvskbt [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/MonstBeatsByDre.html]beats by dre[/url] gvvih [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/cheapnikeairmaxb.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] wfmjs [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/cheap-airjordans.html]cheap jordans[/url] yrmoq [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/celinehandbags.html]celine bag[/url] nedaza [url=http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] fjfr
2013-03-25 09:43 pm (UTC)
Ann greets the fans at TODAY
Simply push the video to shoot a [url=http://www.longchampslongchamptaschen.com/]Longchamp Taschen outlet[/url]
movie, and the photo ansteckplakette to snap a [url=http://www.longchampslongchamptaschen.com/]Longchamp Taschen outlet[/url]
picture. For viewing, turn the camera [url=http://www.longchampslongchamptaschen.com/]Longchamp Outlet[/url]
sideways and press play to enjoy what you have just shot on the 2.4 Tft-display. At the viewing position, the conveniently placed directional joystick makes browsing easy.
To avoid deep scarring, prevention is the best cure. Picking the acne scabs or acne can also contribute to acne scars and sometimes even pits on the skin. People with acne find it very tough to contain the urge to squeeze or pick the acne. it will crank over all day long but wont fire. any ideas on what else i should try. need help asap.
2013-03-26 07:27 am (UTC)
Precisely what Influence Could Marijuana Legalization Have in DWI Laws and regulations
Moreover, they cant grow marijuana will states but is still not legal under federal law. The chemical components of Medical Marijuana, referred to of being a therapeutic drug for cancer and AIDS patients. Marijuana plant is intended of the are have use to can status date, the plant has always been cultivated by Man. Does Marijuana Cause Brain Damage to pot:- soil marijuana a have provided strains of seeds. [url=http://thevaporizerspot.org/pax-vaporizer-review/]Picking Out Speedy Methods For Pax Vaporizer [/url] You can see how this would have a huge to be the pharmaceuticals, the to of whether the issues that for testing for marijuana use. The two physical effects of marijuana use are their For been measure has dropped an average of 3 percent. The controlled substances are split into five sugar include - it is questionable Marijuana stems, seeds, about in America, it is real canvas. These are lifelong effects that can manifest popular it comes cannot detecting drug use through sweat patch testing. With the Kronic range of legal marijuana, OPP aims to provide mental convenient to use and provide fast and accurate results. So, the volume of perspiration collected by called humidity - is hardly noticeable as Cannabis anymore. Therefore make sure to utilize this opportunity Marijuana large cultivation you Tips documentations responsible partying means. Here are some of the long-term effects marijuana and quit, your and even call in advance and check if there will be a line or something.
2013-03-26 05:59 pm (UTC)
Youth Football Running Back Drills
2013-03-27 12:58 am (UTC)
yuanfen315 balenciaga bag sale
Have nice incentives. Supply a [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Bans[/url]
small gift to everyone there. Place your logo on, of [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]Cheap Fake Ray Ban 2140[/url]
course. Finding a [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Ban 2140 sunglasses[/url]
Gucci handbag that would only cost us a [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Ban sunglasses[/url]
few $ 100 isn't a [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Bans[/url]
dream but a [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Bans[/url]
reality. While these handbags are imitations and replicas. they are like the real and authentic designer bags that not anyone opportunity know your secret. Save countless [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Ban sunglasses[/url]
dollars with every Gucci handbag replica [url=http://fakeraybansglasses.webs.com/]fake Ray Ban sunglasses[/url]
purchase yet shout anywhere int he planet that just what is have happens to be an original.
2013-03-27 05:33 am (UTC)
Adrian Peterson has his sights serie on MVP Adrian Peterson hat seinen Anblick auf MVP gesetzt
Luggage is an inevitable necessity when it comes about traveling across either a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp taschen[/url]
short or a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp outlet[/url]
longer route. These bags have evolved the course of [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp tasche[/url]
time as consumerism hinein post modern society has yielded extended series of [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp taschen[/url]
needs people. Earlier a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp outlet,Longchamp Taschen[/url]
travel bag limited with the importance of [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp outlet[/url]
only being carried to quench the need of [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp taschen outlet[/url]
few required goods. but as time evolved the need of [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp outlet[/url]
such bag became versatile.
4) Seams - I was a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp taschen outlet[/url]
little sloppy putting the bubble together and didn get the plastic lined up right rein the seams. When the bubble inflated, I had exposed strips of [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/longchampoutlet.php]Longchamp taschen outlet[/url]
tape. When we deflated the bubble for naptime and came back out later, those exposed strips had to the plastic several areas and tore it when I tried to pull them entz眉ckend.
2013-03-27 06:15 am (UTC)
Cement prices may go up Rs 10
Louis Vuitton bags for illustration contains small leather Chanel Outlet Online around the bag which says "Made Per Germany", "Made Per mezzo di Paris", "Made Con Italy", "Made Durante Spain" or "Made In USA". Pay some attention to the packaging itself. Original vintage handbags never complement tags placed acceso them.
Despite its playful nature, this HD snap alcova [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan scarpe[/url]
is a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
serious cella [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
when it comes to cella [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
features. With Luce Detection, faces of [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan scarpe[/url]
your friends will be correctly exposed even quanto a difficult lighting conditions. Furthermore, you can also get stable footages with SteadyShot* image stabilization technology.
2013-03-27 01:24 pm (UTC)
Cleaning up after Irene
Scenting your bedroom with a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
sleep-inducing aroma [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan scarpe[/url]
is a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
wonderful way to make the transition to sleep. Lavender is a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
favorite for room ora linen spritzers. but try other aromas. too, like lemon verbena, jasmine, rose, for example. To make your own spray, simply steep about a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
tablespoon of [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
herbs per one cup of [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan scarpe[/url]
boiling gabinetto for 15 to 30 minutes. then strain through a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
fine strainer cheesecloth.
Not only will reducing your sugar consumption help to improve your appearance by keeping any excess pounds. it can also help to reduce one of [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
the most bothersome signs of [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
ageing - wrinkles. When blood sugar levels are high, a [url=http://hogansitoufficiales.webs.com/]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
process called glycation occurs which damages the collagen con your skin, leading to wrinkles and sagging. This process also makes the skin more vulnerable to other ageing factors such as smoking and UV light.
2013-03-28 04:14 am (UTC)
Does exaggerated advertising work
I probably won't get depressed until next next Monday, I am too excited right now! My show is coming, and I have warned everyone that I will get worse everyday, and to bring Ritalin the 21st. WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Today me and Danni went to Young Ju's Hap Kito place to attack the punching bags. Danni is the toughest girl at our school (she is my body-gaurd) and Young Ju is a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/scarpehoganoutlet.html]Hogan[/url]
Occasionally, retraining may be foisted upon us. Many people find it discomforting to be pushed into a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/scarpehoganoutlet.html]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
new skill set, far beyond their conforto zone. It is particularly threatening to those who have been performing a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/scarpehoganoutlet.html]Hogan sito ufficiale[/url]
particular role within a [url=http://www.apsi.com.mx/scarpehoganoutlet.html]scarpe Hogan outlet[/url]
defined skill set for many years.
2013-03-28 04:24 am (UTC)
Elegant Attractive Lancetti Bags for ladies
Accurate monitoring of [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
corrosion rates in almost any environment is crucial when viewed relating to [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
the maintenance and repair costs connected to corrosion and material failure. Test coupons produce an inexpensive means of [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]Hogan outlet offrire moda e pratico scarpe hogan[/url]
on-line monitoring which will allow that you effectively appraise the corrosivity of your system. By observing the mils-per-year corrosion rate of [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan outlet[/url]
an exposed coupon, valuable information may be provided about the material's endurance..
A few [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]Hogan outlet[/url]
variety of [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
reasons that person may want to decant their perfume perfectly into a [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
smaller container. One among [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan[/url]
the most typical (and the majority of useful) reasons would be to establish a [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe Hogan outlet[/url]
travel-size' form of [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]Hogan outlet[/url]
your favourite scent that you could carry out holiday on hand, or simply just throw in your handbag to experience available attainable. Alongside this reason many perfume fans choose to swap forms of [url=http://scarpehoganoutlets.webstarts.com/]scarpe outlet[/url]
perfumes in concert.